Choosing between the .44-40 and .45 Colt cartridges for your revolver can feel overwhelming. Both boast a rich history in the Wild West, but their performance characteristics differ significantly. This in-depth comparison will help you determine which cartridge best suits your needs, whether you're a collector, a competitive shooter, or simply fascinated by these iconic rounds.
History and Legacy: A Tale of Two Cartridges
The .44-40 Winchester Center Fire (.44-40 WCF), introduced in 1873, was a revolutionary cartridge. Its widespread adoption, largely due to its use in the iconic Winchester Model 1873 lever-action rifle, cemented its place in American history and popular culture. The versatility of the .44-40—usable in both rifles and revolvers—fueled its immense popularity.
The .45 Colt, also known as the .45 Long Colt, emerged slightly earlier, finding its home primarily in revolvers like the Colt Single Action Army. This cartridge, renowned for its stopping power, became synonymous with the Old West and remains a favorite among enthusiasts today.
Ballistics: Power and Performance Compared
While both cartridges utilize black powder or smokeless powder variations, their ballistic performance differs considerably.
.44-40:
- Caliber: .429 inches (approximately 10.9mm)
- Case Length: 1.2 inches
- Typical Bullet Weight: 200-240 grains
- Velocity: Varies significantly depending on the firearm and powder load, generally ranging from 800-1200 fps.
- Energy: Moderate, suitable for smaller game and self-defense, but less powerful than the .45 Colt.
.45 Colt:
- Caliber: .452 inches (approximately 11.5mm)
- Case Length: 1.285 inches
- Typical Bullet Weight: 200-300 grains, often heavier than .44-40 loads.
- Velocity: Generally lower than the .44-40, usually between 800-1000 fps, though modern loads can achieve higher velocities.
- Energy: Higher than .44-40, delivering greater stopping power, particularly with heavier bullets.
Recoil and Accuracy: A Shooter's Perspective
The noticeably larger diameter and heavier bullets of the .45 Colt contribute to significantly more recoil than the .44-40. While experienced shooters might find this manageable, beginners could find the .45 Colt's recoil somewhat punishing, especially in smaller framed revolvers.
Accuracy can vary depending on the firearm, ammunition, and shooter. However, generally speaking, the .44-40, with its slightly higher velocity and potentially lighter recoil, might offer a marginal edge in accuracy for some shooters.
Availability and Cost: Finding Your Ammunition
Both .44-40 and .45 Colt ammunition are readily available, though the .45 Colt generally has a broader selection of bullet weights, types, and manufacturers. Pricing can fluctuate, but both cartridges are generally considered affordable compared to many modern centerfire cartridges. However, finding black powder loads might require more searching, especially for the .44-40.
Which Cartridge is Right for You?
The "better" cartridge ultimately depends on your priorities:
-
Choose .44-40 if: You prioritize a slightly higher velocity, potentially less recoil, and want a cartridge with a rich history used in both rifles and revolvers. It's a versatile option, though with slightly less stopping power.
-
Choose .45 Colt if: Stopping power is your paramount concern. You appreciate the cartridge's legendary status and don't mind dealing with more significant recoil. The heavier bullet weight offers superior energy transfer.
Ultimately, handling both cartridges and firing them in the specific firearm you own will offer the best personal insight. This comparison provides a solid foundation for your decision, equipping you with the knowledge to make an informed choice.
